Dmitri V. Kovtun arrived in London for the first time in his
life last Oct. 16. He dropped his bags off at a hotel near Piccadilly
Circus and immediately went to meet, also for the first time,
Alexander V. Litvinenko, the former K.G.B. officer whose killing
by radioactive poisoning five weeks later became one of the
most celebrated crimes of the post-cold-war era.
British investigators quickly zeroed in on Mr. Kovtun and an
associate of his, Andrei K. Lugovoi, who both met with Mr. Litvinenko
on Nov. 1, the day he fell ill. But Mr. Kovtun says they have
it backward, maintaining that Oct. 16 was the day that Mr. Litvinenko
exposed him to the poison, polonium 210. “I am far from
thinking that something was premeditated,” Mr. Kovtun
said. “I think things that were not premeditated were
happening.”
Much uncertainty still shrouds Mr. Litvinenko’s death
on Nov. 23, at 43, but Mr. Kovtun’s version — outlined
in his most extensive and detailed interview, and impossible
to verify independently — illustrates the starkly divergent
view of the Litvinenko affair as seen from Moscow. It also suggests
that sorting out the truth may ultimately be impossible, given
the complex, secretive web of associations that bind Russia
to its willing and unwilling exiles in London.
In British news media accounts not disputed by Scotland Yard,
investigators have focused on a meeting that Mr. Kovtun and
Mr. Lugovoi had with Mr. Litvinenko on Nov. 1. Together, they
have been portrayed as secret agents sent to avenge Mr. Litvinenko’s
betrayal of the K.G.B.’s domestic successor, the Federal
Security Service.
Here in Russia, by contrast, prosecutors are investigating
what they called an attempted murder of Mr. Kovtun from polonium
exposure. (The extent of Mr. Lugovoi’s exposure is unclear.)
In their few statements, prosecutors have suggested the possibility
that Russian tycoons living in exile, including those who once
ran Yukos Oil, ordered Mr. Litvinenko’s killing and, evidently,
tainted Mr. Kovtun in the process.
Mr. Litvinenko’s relatives and associates abroad, in
turn, say the Kremlin or security services ordered Mr. Litvinenko’s
killing and are now trying to muddy public perceptions and hamper
justice.
Whatever the truth of the case, Mr. Kovtun and Mr. Lugovoi,
old schoolmates, friends and business associates, are at the
center of what happened in London beginning the day that Mr.
Kovtun arrived, traveling with Mr. Lugovoi and fulfilling a
dream from his days of childhood English lessons “to see
Westminster Abbey and other things” in London.
Everywhere they went on Oct. 16 — Erinys, an international
security company on Grosvenor Street; Itsu, a sushi bar on Piccadilly,
and the Best Western Premier Shaftesbury Hotel near Piccadilly
Circus — later showed traces of polonium 210, according
to British health officials. So did the Parkes Hotel, where
they checked in the next day, unhappy with their first choice
of accommodations.
Mr. Kovtun, who is 41, spoke in Mr. Lugovoi’s office
on the second floor of the Radisson SAS Slavyanskaya, one of
Moscow’s fanciest hotels. Mr. Lugovoi, 40, spoke in a
separate interview there, and he also went to lengths to challenge
the perception that has taken root in the West.
Mr. Kovtun is the only person ever officially identified —
by a prosecutor in Germany — as a possible suspect, specifically
a suspect in the unlawful handling of polonium while he visited
his former wife in Hamburg from Oct. 28 to Oct. 31, before returning
to London. He denied that.
Whatever the source, however, the traces of polonium followed
Mr. Kovtun back to Moscow aboard a British Airways flight and
to Germany, where he had served as a captain in the Soviet Red
Army’s Main Intelligence Administration. He said he never
served in the K.G.B. or its domestic successor.
After the Soviet Union collapsed, he remained in Germany and
married a German. Although now divorced, he said, he and his
former wife remain close, and she has agreed to meet with Russian
investigators.
“When they began to say the address where traces of polonium
were found, we realized that we visited those addresses only
on the 16th and the 17th,” Mr. Kovtun said, referring
to his first visit to London in October. “I thought my
contact was there, since they found it in Germany. It could
have only been brought from there. And when I realized those
traces stayed for a long time, I thought they could have only
come from there. I had never had any contact with polonium or
with any radioactive substance.”
Mr. Kovtun said he could not explain how he was exposed. Nor
would he speculate as to whether he believed Mr. Litvinenko
had already been exposed somehow or whether he was carrying
the material.
Nuclear experts said that if Mr. Litvinenko had absorbed a
lethal dose on Oct. 16, the symptoms would have appeared almost
immediately. That did not happen until the night of Nov. 1,
after his meeting with Mr. Kovtun and Mr. Lugovoi.
Mr. Kovtun runs Global Project, a business consulting company
he founded after returning to Moscow from Germany in 2003. It
specializes in helping foreign companies — including some
in Britain — to invest in Russia. Mr. Lugovoi, like Mr.
Litvinenko, is a veteran of the K.G.B. department that guarded
Soviet and later Russian senior leaders. Both went on to work
closely with Boris A. Berezovsky, a billionaire tycoon. Mr.
Lugovoi now owns Ninth Wave, a security company. On their first
visit in October, Mr. Kovtun and Mr. Lugovoi said, Mr. Litvinenko
seemed eager to introduce the Russians to his business contacts
in London, including those at Erinys.
Mr. Kovtun said he did not have a favorable first impression
of Mr. Litvinenko. “He was very politicized,” he
said. “If he had a chance to talk about politics, he would
do it willingly. And he spoke of absurd things.”
He did not elaborate on the subjects of Mr. Litvinenko’s
talks, but he suggested that they included current affairs in
Russia. Nevertheless, the three men met again on Oct. 17, having
lunch at a Chinese restaurant.
After his visit to Germany, Mr. Kovtun returned to London on
the morning of Nov. 1 aboard a plane belonging to an airline,
Germanwings, that did not test for contamination, German officials
have said.
He and Mr. Lugovoi did not plan to meet Mr. Litvinenko on that
day, but they said that Mr. Litvinenko called them insistently
on Nov. 1 to arrange a meeting. Mr. Kovtun said he had been
having meetings at an investment company called Eco3 Capital,
whose address is listed as 58 Grosvenor Street, a short walk
from the Mayfair Millennium Hotel, where the Russians were staying.
British health officials said last November that polonium traces
were also found at 58 Grosvenor Street. A representative of
Eco3 Capital declined to discuss Mr. Kovtun’s visit, except
to say that his business had been with a client, not directly
with the investment company.
The three men agreed, at last, to meet later that afternoon
at the Pine Bar in the Mayfair Millennium, where traces of polonium
were found and seven members of the bar staff were exposed to
small, nonfatal doses. Traces were also found in rooms, apparently
those occupied by the Russians.
Mr. Lugovoi and Mr. Kovtun both noted that British and Russian
investigators had cautioned them not to discuss the details
of the investigation itself. In particular, both were wary of
discussing what happened in the bar — including whether
Mr. Litvinenko drank anything — but they described the
meeting as short and largely unnecessary, given that they were
planning to meet the next morning.
Mr. Kovtun described him as agitated. He said he looked unwell.
“We did not speak with Litvinenko a long time, but he
looked strange, and he was sitting next to me,” he said.
“He kept talking. He didn’t close his mouth.”
When their names first surfaced, both men came forward and
volunteered to meet with British investigators. They met with
officials at the British Embassy in Moscow on Nov. 23, a few
hours before Mr. Litvinenko died and before specialists determined
that he had been exposed to polonium. Traces of polonium were
later discovered at the embassy.
Mr. Kovtun went to the hospital for a test that showed he was
“seriously polluted” with polonium, though he would
not say exactly how much, citing his agreement with British
and Russian investigators. He was treated and feels fine now,
he said, dismissing as a lie a report in December by the Interfax
news agency that he had slipped into a coma.
He did shave his head, prompting a flurry of speculation about
his health when he appeared in a television interview, but he
said he did it as a precaution since radioactive material could
linger in his hair. His hair is growing back.
Both men said they had cooperated extensively with British
and Russian investigators, one of whom, Mr. Lugovoi said, assured
him that he was not a suspect. “Andrei, you are only a
witness,” he said he recalled the investigator saying.
Other witnesses have included Mr. Lugovoi’s family members
and his personal secretary in Moscow, who never went to London.
Investigators in London and Moscow declined to discuss the
case, but Scotland Yard did announce that it had presented the
case to the Crown Prosecution Service, where officials will
decide whether to bring charges. Those could come at any time,
or never.
The Russians, meantime, said they were victims of circumstance,
of bias and preconceptions and of the poison that killed Mr.
Litvinenko.
“I want you to understand one thing,” Mr. Lugovoi
said. “Myself and Dmitri Kovtun, we consider ourselves
an injured party.”
Steven Lee Myers reported from Moscow, and Alan Cowell from
Moscow and London.