The Japanese government has warned doctors that Tamiflu, the
drug being stockpiled around the world as a defence against
a bird flu pandemic, should not be prescribed to teenagers for
fear that it can lead to bizarre and self-destructive behaviour.
Tokyo’s Ministry of Health and Welfare today instructed
the Japanese distributor of the drug to include a warning not
to give the drug to patients aged between 10 and 19, after reports
that at least 18 Japanese children taking Tamiflu have died
as a result of irrational behaviour.
Concern over Tamiflu will complicate international preparations
for a catastrophic bird flu pandemic, against which it is seen
as the final line of defence. A
However, the European Medicine Agency (EMEA), which licences
the drug in Europe, said that there was no equivalent warning
in Europe as they had not found any link between the drug and
any deaths.
Japan consumes 60 per cent of the world’s Tamiflu, the
drug also known as oseltamivir, and manufactured by the Swiss
pharmaceutical company Roche. Britain has purchased enough courses
of the drug to treat 25 per cent of the population if there
was an outbreak of a bird flu pandemic.
Despite scores of deaths in south-east Asia, there have been
no cases of human bird flu in Japan, and the 8.6 million people
who receive the drug every year are suffering from the common
form of human influenza.
But for the past three years, there have been alarming stories
of young people succumbing to fits of self-destructive behaviour
while receiving Tamiflu.
Relatives who believe that their children were adversely affected
by the drug have formed a lobby group to demand its withdrawal
from sale.
One of the most disturbing cases was in February 2004 when
a 17-year old boy took one capsule of Tamiflu at his home in
Gifu prefecture, central Japan. No one was at home to witness
what happened next, but he appears to have left the house in
his pyjamas, walked barefoot through a snowstorm, climbed over
two fences and stepped in front of an oncoming truck. The driver
told police that he was smiling at the moment of impact.
At the end of last month, a fourteen year old boy in the city
of Sendai told his mother that he was going to the toilet, but
then walked out of the front door of his eleven storey apartment.
His mother ran out to see him straddling the four foot guard
rail and despite her cries of warning he fell to his death in
the car park below. He had taken two Tamiflu capsules, the first
day of a five day prescribed course for influenza.
According to Japan’s health ministry, most of the 54
Japanese who died after taking Tamiflu by October last year,
succumbed to liver or other organ failure, most likely caused
by influenza. But 16 of them were children aged 16 or under,
several of whom had exhibited “abnormal” behaviour.
The drug is already sold in Japan with a general warning that
users may have psychological side effects including abnormal
behaviour and hallucinations.
Proponents of the drug, however, argue that this is more likely
to be caused by the flu itself, than by Tamiflu, and that there
is no scientific evidence of any link between the drug and the
violent deaths.
“Tamiflu has now been used in over 45 million influenza
patients worldwide and treatment with Tamiflu has proven successful
in reducing the duration and severity of the disease,”
Roche said in statement today.
“Reports of such events leading to death are extremely
rare, occurring in around 1 out of every 5 million influenza
patients treated. No causal link between such events and Tamiflu
has been established."
The statement said that US health insurance records in 1999-2006
indicated that psychiatric symptoms were lower in influenza
patients taking Tamiflu than those not taking Tamiflu.
Eduard Holdener, Roche's Chief Medical Officer, said: "Patient
safety is a primary concern for Roche and since the introduction
of Tamiflu, Roche has continuously monitored and reviewed post-marketing
safety information and provides regular updates to the regulatory
agencies."
Anti-Tamiflu campaigners criticised today's decision to provide
“safety information”, but not remove the drug from
sale for being an inadequate and irresolute step.
“The government has kept saying there is no link between
Tamiflu and the deaths,” said Ryuko Hatano, whose son
died after taking the drug. “I cannot understand the ministry’s
attitude in which they cannot move a step nor a half step until
they see the next victim.”
Last month the European Agency for the EMEA, which licences
the drug in Europe, including Britain, recommended that advice
be given to doctors stating that psychological disorders have
been reported in users of Tamiflu in Japan.
However, a spokesman for the EMEA said: “There is no
warning equivalent in Europe for Tamiflu. The current situation
is that we see there is no causal relationship between Tamiflu
and these events.”